Schizoaffective disorder: A challenging diagnosis

Mr. C, age 34, presented to the emergency department with his wife because of increasingly bizarre behavior. He reported auditory and visual hallucinations, and believed that the “mob had ordered a hit” against him. He had threatened to shoot his wife and children, which led to his arrest and being briefly jailed. In jail, he was agitated, defecated on the floor, and disrobed. His wife reported that Mr. C had a long history of bipolar disorder and had experienced his first manic episode and hospitalization at age 17. Since then, he had been treated with many different antidepressants, antipsychotics, and mood stabilizers.

Mr. C was admitted to the hospital, where he developed a catatonic syndrome that was treated with a course of electroconvulsive therapy. He was eventually stabilized with olanzapine, 20 mg by mouth nightly, with moderate improvement in his symptoms, although he never fully returned to baseline.

Over the next 8 years, Mr. C was often noncompliant with medication and frequently was hospitalized for mania. His symptoms included poor sleep, grandiosity, pressured speech, racing and disorganized thoughts, increased risk-taking behavior (ie, driving at excessive speeds), and hyperreligiosity (ie, speaking with God). Mr. C also occasionally used methamphetamine, cannabis, and cocaine. Although he had responded well to treatment early in the course of his illness, as he entered his late 30s, his response was less complete, and by his 40s, Mr. C was no longer able to function independently. He eventually was prescribed a long-acting injectable antipsychotic, paliperidone palmitate, 156 mg monthly. Eventually, his family was no longer able to care for him at home, so he was admitted to a residential care facility.

In this facility, based on the long-standing nature of Mr. C’s psychotic disorder and frequency with which he presented with mania, his clinicians changed his diagnosis to schizoaffective disorder, bipolar type. It had become clear that mood symptoms comprised >50% of the total duration of his illness.

Schizoaffective disorder (SAD) often has been used as a diagnosis for patients who have an admixture of mood and psychotic symptoms whose diagnosis is uncertain. Its hallmark is the presence of symptoms of a major mood episode (either a depressive or manic episode) concurrent with symptoms characteristic of schizophrenia, such as delusions, hallucinations, or disorganized speech.¹

SAD is a controversial diagnosis. There has been inadequate research regarding the epidemiology, course, etiologic factors, and treatment of this disorder. Debate continues to swirl around its conceptualization; some experts view SAD as an independent disorder, while others see SAD as either a form of schizophrenia or a mood disorder.¹ In this review, we describe the classification of SAD and its features, diagnosis, and treatment.

An evolving diagnosis

The term schizoaffective was first used by Jacob Kasanin, MD, in 1933.² He described 9 patients with “acute schizoaffective psychoses,” each of whom had an abrupt onset. The term was used in the first edition of the DSM as a subtype of schizophrenia.³ In DSM-I, the “schizo-affective type” was defined as a diagnosis for patients with a “significant admixture of schizophrenic and affective reactions.”³ Diagnostic criteria for SAD were developed for DSM-III-R, published in 1987.⁴ These criteria continued to evolve with subsequent editions of the DSM.

Continue to: DSM-5 provides...