Pain Out of Proportion to a Fracture

A 57-year-old woman sustained an injury to her left shoulder during a fall down stairs. She presented to the emergency department, where a physician ordered x-rays that a radiologist interpreted as depicting a simple fracture.

The patient claimed that the radiologist misread the x-rays and that the emergency medicine (EM) physician failed to realize her pain was out of proportion to a fracture. She said the EM physician should have ordered additional tests and sought a radiologic consult. The patient contended that she had actually dislocated her shoulder and that the delay in treatment caused her condition to worsen, leaving her unable to use her left hand.

In addition to the radiologist and the EM physician, two nurses were named as defendants. The plaintiff maintained that they had failed to notify the physician when her condition deteriorated.

OUTCOME
A $2.75 million settlement was reached. The hospital, the EM physician, and the nurses were responsible for $1.5 million and the radiologist, $1.25 million.

Continue for David M. Lang's comments >>